Since the formation of the Earth 4.2 billion years ago, hot rock from the interior of the planet has cooled off and developed crystals that accumulated over millions of years, forming surface rocks with a layered composition, referred to as continental crust. Geologic evidence of how continental crust formed comes from large, ancient crustal blocks, called cratons. Cratons have existed for billions of years and form the cores of continents.
Scientists have shown that the upper 10 to 15 kilometers (6 to 9 miles) of continental crust contains high concentrations of elements like uranium and thorium that decay and release heat over time, referred to as radiogenic elements. However, the lower 20 kilometers (12 miles) of crust has very few radiogenic elements. The cause of this planetary-scale differentiation is highly questioned, as geoscientists don’t know what formation processes could produce this unique characteristic.
Earlier researchers suggested that changes in the concentration of radiogenic elements could occur when tectonic plates collide. Plate collision induces temperatures in the lower crust high enough to melt minerals that contain uranium and thorium, like zircon and monazite. The newly melted minerals form magma, which then rises and crystallizes in the upper crust. To test whether this process formed the layered continental crust, researchers Andrew J. Smye and Peter B. Keleman incorporated geochemical data from studies worldwide into a mathematical model comparing how concentrations of radiogenic elements vary under different temperatures.
The team separated their global analyses into 2 categories of rocks that were buried deep in the crust and subjected to intense pressures and temperatures, via a process known as metamorphism. The first category included rocks formed from the accumulation of eroded grains buried in the deep crust that are subjected to high pressures and temperatures, called metasedimentary rocks. The second category included rocks formed when magma rises from the deep Earth and solidifies before experiencing high pressures and temperatures, called metaigneous rocks.
The researchers analyzed 3 subcategories from each of the 2 types of deep-crustal rocks. The first was rocks that experienced no intense pressure or temperature, the second was rocks subjected to 650 to 900°C (about 1,200 to 1,650°F), and the third was rocks subjected to 900 to 1,100°C (about 1,650 to 2,000°F). The researchers modeled the geochemistry of the 3 rock types at different temperatures to determine whether ultra-high-temperature metamorphism could cause crustal differentiation of radiogenic elements.
Smye and Keleman found that monazite doesn’t melt in either metasedimentary or metaigneous rocks at temperatures below 900°C, as indicated by the relatively high thorium content in these deep-crustal rocks. Alternatively, they found that above 900°C, uranium and thorium concentrations decreased in metasedimentary rocks, suggesting that minerals like zircon and monazite were melting. The melted minerals enter magma and rise into the upper crust, leaving behind metasedimentary rocks depleted in radiogenic elements by around 0.10 ppm.
The team concluded that the enrichment of uranium and thorium in the upper continental crust requires temperatures greater than 900°C to initiate the melting of zircon and monazite in the lower crust. Temperatures above 900°C are linked to the movement and collision of continental plates. This result suggests that evidence of Earth’s differentiation has been preserved for more than 3 billion years, spanning most of the planet’s geological history. Since stable continental crust formed, uranium and thorium enrichment in the upper crust has consistently recorded layering produced by ultra-high temperature metamorphism.
